Quantum
The Bapat-Sunder eigenvalue conjecture fails over the reals
Publication: quant-ph updates on arXiv.org
Author: Logan R. Chalmers
Source published: 19/11/2026, 05:00:00 UTC
Briefing created: 19/11/2026, 05:17:59 UTC
Based on a feed excerpt; full article content has not been acquired. Source evidence retrieved 19/11/2026, 05:13:24 UTC.
Briefings
A 2026 study by Drury and collaborators disproves the Bapat-Sunder eigenvalue conjecture, showing that the largest eigenvalue of a Gram matrix is not always the largest eigenvalue of the matrix formed by permuting its entries. The research provides a counterexample using a rank-4, 32x32 integer Gram matrix and an integer vector where the Rayleigh quotient exceeds the per(A) value. This result resolves the conjecture negatively over both the complex and real number fields, with counterexamples existing for every order n greater than or equal to 32.
Key points
- Drury disproved the Bapat-Sunder conjecture by constructing a counterexample over the real numbers using a rank-4, 32x32 integer Gram matrix and an integer vector.
- The counterexample demonstrates that the largest eigenvalue of a Gram matrix is not necessarily the largest eigenvalue of the matrix formed by permuting its entries.
Context
The Bapat-Sunder eigenvalue conjecture, proposed in 1986, asked whether the largest eigenvalue of a Gram matrix is always the largest eigenvalue of the matrix formed by permuting its entries. Drury had previously disproved this over the complex field in 2018, but the conjecture remained open for real matrices. This new work resolves the conjecture negatively over both fields by providing explicit counterexamples.
Limitations
The evidence is a preprint from arXiv:2611.23269v1, so verification status is uncertain. The counterexamples are limited to rank-4, 32x32 matrices, and while the paper claims counterexamples exist for every order n>=32, this is a claim rather than a verified fact for all n. The application to quantum optics is described as a direction of relative arrival-time delays, not a confirmed physical phenomenon.
Generated by Bittrees-hosted qwen35-2b sha256:aaf42c8b7c3c on 19/11/2026, 05:17:59 UTC. Based on publisher-provided feed evidence; may not cover the full original article. Check the source for details.
View archived briefing on IPFS
bafybeiew4oulr6b7lgigdiow7hc2fkgrkkylq374gm2founboh6l4fnppi